Dispelling the Annuity Myth: Does the Insurance Company Profit When You Die?

About Joe Brown

Brown Advisory Group, LLC
Joe works in Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota, Florida, and Arizona, protecting millions of dollars in retirement assets. Joe and his clients sleep well at night, knowing their retirement funds are protected. There is something truly wonderful about being able to help people have peace of mind about their financial future. Joe desires to give you that same peace of mind. Joe Brown and his wife, Pamela, reside in Wisconsin. As President of Brown Advisory Group, LLC, and a host of Safe Money and Income Radio Show, Joe has over 30 years’ experience working with people near retirement or already in retirement.

Many individuals have likely encountered the annuity concept in their quest to create a sound retirement plan. However, a pervasive myth is frequently attached to this financial product: the supposed win-win situation for insurance companies when annuity holders pass away. Today, we’ll delve into this misconception, dissect its origins, and debunk it by presenting a well-rounded understanding of how annuities work.

In their simplest form, annuities are contracts between individuals and insurance companies, promising a stream of income over a specified period in exchange for an upfront investment. There are various annuities, each with its terms, benefits, and drawbacks. The two most common types are immediate and deferred annuities, further divided into fixed, variable, and fixed indexed ((FIA) ones.

The “annuity lie,” as it has been dubbed, is a misinterpretation, suggesting that insurance companies pocket the remaining balance of your annuity upon your death. It stems primarily from a misunderstanding of life annuities, or annuities without a specific period or death benefit. In this case, payments cease upon the annuitant’s death, and any remaining balance reverts to the insurance company. However, presenting this as a blanket truth for all annuities is misleading.

In reality, most annuity options include beneficiary provisions for heirs. For instance, term-certain annuities guarantee payments for a specified period. If the annuitant dies before this period ends, the remaining payments continue to a beneficiary. Joint-and-survivor annuities ensure payments continue to a spouse or partner upon the annuitant’s death. Variable and indexed annuities often include death benefits, ensuring the annuitant’s heirs receive the accumulated value of the annuity.

Insurance companies make their profits from annuities through investment gains on the money invested which may be in excess of the promised returns to the annuitant. They operate on the law of large numbers, pooling funds from many annuitants and investing them to generate returns. They use actuarial science to estimate the longevity of their client pool and determine the payout rates. This shared risk among annuitants allows the insurer to provide guaranteed income streams.

Moreover, insurance companies are not in the business of gambling on their clients’ lifespans. A premature death doesn’t equate to a financial windfall for the insurer. On the contrary, annuitants who live beyond their actuarial life expectancy may receive more than their original investment, funded by the insurance company.

The narrative that insurance companies pocket the residual value of annuities upon the holder’s death oversimplifies the concept and neglects to consider the many types of annuities available. It also undermines annuities’ critical role in providing a guaranteed income stream, an essential aspect of retirement planning in an uncertain economic climate.

If considering an annuity, it’s essential to understand its terms fully, particularly regarding what happens upon death. It’s also important to shop around, as terms can vary among insurance companies. Consult with a financial advisor or annuity expert to clarify any misconceptions and to ensure the annuity aligns with your financial goals and estate planning needs.

The myth that insurance companies profit from the untimely deaths of their annuitants is just that – a myth. The reality is more nuanced, reflecting a complex system based on investment strategy, risk pooling, actuarial science, and myriad annuity options. Investing time in understanding these factors and seeking professional guidance to navigate the annuity landscape is always prudent.

Don’t let misconceptions guide your financial journey. Reach out to an annuity expert today and start exploring the true potential of annuities tailored to your specific needs and goals.

  • The misconception that insurance companies profit from the early deaths of annuity holders stems from a misunderstanding of the risk-pooling nature of insurance and the variety of annuity options available.
  • Insurance companies generate revenue from annuities through investment gains and fees, not from the untimely death of annuitants, with the shared risk among annuitants allowing the insurer to provide guaranteed income streams.
  • It is crucial for individuals considering annuities to fully understand the terms, consult with a financial advisor, and choose an annuity type that aligns with their financial goals and estate planning needs.

Many people have learned about the power of using the Safe Money approach to reduce volatility. Our Safe Money Guide is in its 20th edition and is available for free.  

It is an Instant Download.  Here is a link to download our guide: 

Safe Money Guide – Annuity.com

About Joe Brown

Joe works in Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota, Florida, and Arizona, protecting millions of dollars in retirement assets. Joe and his clients sleep well at night, knowing their retirement funds are protected. There is something truly wonderful about being able to help people have peace of mind about their financial future. Joe desires to give you that same peace of mind. Joe Brown and his wife, Pamela, reside in Wisconsin. As President of Brown Advisory Group, LLC, and a host of Safe Money and Income Radio Show, Joe has over 30 years’ experience working with people near retirement or already in retirement.

View The Best Annuity Rates Available Now

Annuities are a safe and reliable investment. They can transform your savings into a more predictable income. Speak with one of our qualified financial professionals today to find out how an annuity can offer you guaranteed monthly income for life.

Our unique system of “Pooled and Shared” articles by our authors, our outside contributors, and writing assistants provides efficiency, enhanced collaboration, and greater topic accessibility. This allows for a better utilization of content and productivity while delivering meaningful content to our readers.

Content in our posted articles is deemed to be accurate but topics, facts and laws can change. It is always a good idea to verify facts before making decisions. Always seek authorized and professional advice regarding financial decisions which includes investing, annuity purchases, tax planning, changes in a financial portfolio and retirement planning.

Share This Entry:

In This Article

Protect Your Retirement

Our 20th edition of The Safe Money Guide, the standard of the industry.

Recent Posts

Archives